900°
9.3

Sea of ​​Thieves review - It's a Pirates Life for Me | Elite Gamer

Sea of Thieves is a colourful pirate adventure where you go loot with friends and compete against other players. Elite Gamer played with a few loyal shipmates to find out if the game is only a short-term comedy affair or if we can expect a long-term playable experience.

Read Full Story >>
elitegamer.com
lptmg2228d ago ShowReplies(14)
IamTylerDurden12228d ago (Edited 2227d ago )

I have never heard of this site, they aren't on Metacritic.

I have a very hard time believing it's a 9.3 considering all the complaints i've heard.

It sounds like..

A severe lack of content

Server issues

Mostly repetitive fetch quests

Lack of gun variety/poor ground combat

Lack of character progression giving little incentive to keep playing

darthv722227d ago

Guess you need to play it for yourself if you want to know if the review is correct or the complaints are correct.

SegaGamer2227d ago

I have been reading comments on Reddit, and it seems like this game is turning out how i expected it to turn out.... bland. I had a feeling this game was going to be over hyped when they kept showing us videos of those hipsters playing the game, it was like they were trying to sell it to us through their reactions rather than gameplay itself. No wonder why the trailer was a live action one, it's because there isn't much of the gameplay to actually show.

People will get bored of this game quickly, fetch quests and cosmetics is nowhere near enough to keep people interested.

whothedog2227d ago

What is the end goal or reason to make someone want to keep playing, I seen a lot of fetch quests with this so far.

Jinger2227d ago

@Whothedog

To become pirate and then captain legend. Once that happens high level missions are unlocked for you. there is a secret place you unlock by becoming a captain legend that they haven't even talked about. I have even found a mysterious stranger who will start giving you other missions once you reach level 5 in each merchant... there is plenty to keep going for besides the fact that the game is just fun to play.

warriorcase2227d ago (Edited 2227d ago )

I have this feeling and have mentioned it on the forums and reddit. I have been playing since alpha testing and was blown away at first but each test I thought the lack of content was worrying but dismissed it because it was still just testing afterall. Now including the last 2 days of playing final release I would guess after the initial fun there will be a major drop off until more content is released. The ship to ship battles are amazing but alot of other systems lack any depth at all. Should be noted that the game can be very fun but people need to curb their expectations. You can see more discussion here where longer term players are saying much of the same:

https://www.reddit.com/r/Se...

notachance2227d ago (Edited 2227d ago )

It's not much different from the beta, whoever folks that said "but the beta is just a small preview of the final game, there's like so much more things in the final game" can kiss me arse.

I bought it and played 4-5 hours
I'm already bored

this is a $20 game being sold for $60 so that the game pass owner could feel they save a lot of money

Artemidorus2227d ago Show
chuckyj12227d ago

So... You have no first-hand knowledge... And question a reviewer who played the game and voiced his opinion?

This is direct from the review you didn't read...
"The visuals were improved and there was far more to do in the game than there was in the Beta."

Kiwi662227d ago

So just because you haven't heard of them doesn't make them irrelevant

Professor_K2227d ago

Well gee man, have you ever considered that maybe, just MAAAYBE

WE all have different choices and opinions?

Kribwalker2227d ago Show
DarXyde2227d ago (Edited 2227d ago )

Let's be reasonable.

A "lack of content" can be remedied. Microsoft appears to have taken to the "living game" idea where they keep updating games over time, especially a game like this with a multiplayer emphasis. To be fair, Street Fighter V and Gran Turismo Sport also had a severe lack of content and they're much fuller experiences now.

Server issues can be remedied.

Repetitive fetch quests are not atypical. Games like The Witcher and Horizon: Zero Dawn are exceptions in that the quests don't come off as repetitive (or fetch quests, really). The game can continue to evolve.

Gun variety is a strange complaint. They're pirates. What exactly are you expecting them to have? They're not going to find something like a Plasma Cutter from Dead Space in a cave. Combat is a valid complaint, I suppose.

I can't say much on character progression since it seems like we don't really have a full picture of the game yet. But with Game Pass prices, why not?

I don't take much interest in the game; the premise sounds legitimately fun, but the genre isn't my cup of tea (being a first-person title). Still, if this is an early indication of what's to come, I'd say Rare did a great job of creating a game that embodies the expectations created for them generations ago. If it's a great game, awesome. I hope it does well so Rare, with some confidence, funding, and reassurances, can create a sequel to Conker's Bad Fur Day. I'd need to see at least 3 games in a row from them that are critically acclaimed first though.

2227d ago
2227d ago
meka26112227d ago

Dude you are on every article about this game. Did it kill your family or something?

+ Show (13) more repliesLast reply 2227d ago
Professor_K2227d ago

Awesome

Great job Rare

Golly good F**ing show 😃

2227d ago
The Wood2227d ago

Enjoyment is the real score. Each to their own

+ Show (2) more repliesLast reply 2227d ago
JayRyu2228d ago

Great! Here's hoping that MS continues to right the ship for Xbox gamers!

Lokii2227d ago

Not a good enough attempt here though

JayRyu2227d ago

It is a good start. New IP with decent reviews. Let's hope it keeps being improved upon. I'm having a lot of fun with this game.

Dragonscale2227d ago Show
2227d ago
slate912228d ago

Hopefully we keep seeing scores like this!

travestyj2227d ago (Edited 2227d ago )

It won't. This is some no name site no one has ever heard of releasing an early review just for clicks.

Ausbo2227d ago

I think it would earn more clicks if it gave it a 2/10

gamex22227d ago

Em, Elite Gamer is definitely not a no name site. You should do your research rather than making up random facts to suit your agenda...

travestyj2227d ago (Edited 2227d ago )

lol yes it is a no name site. it's not even registered on Metacritic and they have a lot of no name sites. No one cares about their reviews

They do one bad article a day. It's some dudes hobby blog site lol

lptmg2227d ago

you just said no one has ever heard of them but you know they do a bad article a day?

travestyj2227d ago (Edited 2227d ago )

I obviously just checked out there site because it was linked here. Shouldn't have to explain that to you. There are dates on their "articles"

+ Show (2) more repliesLast reply 2227d ago
Thatguy-3102227d ago ShowReplies(1)
JayRyu2227d ago

Yes me too. It's off to a good start IMO. There is room for improvement with patches and stuff...cough.. Kracken full body...cough. but I'm having fun with the game and that's why I think it gonna do well.

slate912227d ago

I totally agree. I was a bit disappointed with the krakken underwater haha. But it has a lot of potential. And even the base game is good enough as it is. Just going to keep getting better

2227d ago
Jinger2228d ago

Great score... but how the F did they determine it's a 9.3 already? I mean did they even get to the end game stuff? I know MS didn't give out really early codes, the most anyone got was a day early for streamers...

So not sure I can really trust this review. I mean I'm playing it and I'm not sure I'd give it a 9/10 until I see what the end game has to offer.

PowerOfTheCloud2228d ago

Clickbait score for traffic!🤐

2227d ago
Cyborgg2228d ago

I wonder if this review will show up on Opencritic or metacritic

Cyborgg2227d ago

Sea of Thieves is a gorgeous game that is a blast when you enter and explore the game for the first time. However, after a few hours of playing you begin to wonder whether the game was originally a tech demo with content as an after thought. In comparison to all games that have come out by the beginning of 2018,Sea of Thieves doesn't seem to excel over any of them in any area other than the beauty of sea travel. The developers claim it is "a game as a service" yet compared to other games of that nature like Minecraft and Fortnite, this game is a fully priced $60 and comes with significantly less customization and incentive to play. The core gameplay grows stale after a few voyages, and you begin to grow weary of the frequent encounter with other players camping at the outposts. The game could potentially be full of life in a year or two, but as of now it is simply a gorgeous game that leaves much to be desired.

Lennoxb632228d ago

There is no "end game" for games like Sea of Thieves.

Jinger2228d ago

Yes there is. They have end game missions once you become pirate legend and captain legend etc.

343_Guilty_Spark2228d ago

Don’t need to reach the endgame in many games to find them exceptional

Cmv382228d ago

Destiny 1 is a great example. Games with an end game should be reviewed with that in mind.

rainslacker2227d ago

Does this game have an end Game?

rainslacker2227d ago

I read your description in another comment after asking. Was just curious.

bluefox7552227d ago

Because it's not a serious review. Any objective gamer dismisses early reviews like this on ANY game. It seems everyone has a vested interested in this game doing well or not well though. It's a shame when people care more about review scores than whether or not the game is actually good.

+ Show (4) more repliesLast reply 2227d ago
lptmg2228d ago

did those guys play the game for 1h before writing the review?

TheCouchHobo2228d ago

Nope, it released for us reviewers yesterday so had LOADS of time to play it ;)

Brazz2228d ago

So, did you guys reach end game contend, like pirate legend? Did you guys reach secreat hideout whit new quests and cosmetics?

gamex22228d ago

Reaching endgame isn't required for a review, it's simply to play most of the game and decide wether it's with the purchase. A review isn't a walkthrough, it's a evaluation on whether or not the game is worth buying. And clearly it is.

OffRoadKing2228d ago

It only takes one day to experience everything worth writing a review about for this game, that's not confidence inspiring.

TheCouchHobo2228d ago

You mean two days, this review was started yesterday XD

Nitrowolf22228d ago

Thats not a whole lot of time to review a game IMO, that is rather rushed TBH

SegaGamer2227d ago

"You mean two days, this review was started yesterday"

Eh?

If you started the review yesterday and you finished it today, that means it took you one day to review the game.........i don't know where you got two days from. With a lack of basic understanding of how time works, i think it's hard to trust what you say in your review.

rainslacker2227d ago

I think the question people are implying is how can you judge the long term appeal of the game after one day. I can have tons of fun in a new mmo the first day....even the first week...buying can easily get boring if the available content isn't varied enough, or the end game is dull and short.

Sometimes what is fun in small or short doses, doesn't translate well to long term experience.

notachance2227d ago

dude even NMS is fun the first few hours, games like this the long-term aspect is an important point to include in the review

gamex22227d ago Show
+ Show (6) more repliesLast reply 2227d ago
Show all comments (219)
220°

Could Helldivers 2 Be PlayStation’s Sea Of Thieves?

Opinion: Why Helldivers 2 and Sea of Thieves, despite their obvious differences, are very much the same for PlayStation and Xbox

Read Full Story >>
gamersocialclub.ca
Magatsuhi5d ago

Tired of these MS fluff pieces. Sot does not come close to what hd2 does.

danno_omen5d ago

You should probably read the article then, I wasn’t comparing the actual games

Cacabunga4d ago

How can it be PS sea of thieves when SOT is on PS5? Were you just in a hurry to write something??

4d ago
MrNinosan4d ago

Make a less click baiting headline next time, and people might read bwfore judging.

z2g4d ago (Edited 4d ago )

people don't understand nuance or abstract thought. they just hear two games and decide they like one better than the other so the one they don't like can't be anything close to the one they like. I get that you are speaking in a larger context, not a direct comparison. it could be a huge community building game that has a long burn that could also extend to other platforms and or be cross platform. it could be like sea of thieves in that regard etc. never mind the knuckle draggers on this site. its impossible to have a reasonable, objective conversation here.

+ Show (1) more replyLast reply 4d ago
redknight805d ago

I know the headline is a bit bonkers but it is otherwise a good read apart from that.

InUrFoxHole5d ago

Lol you didn't read it. It's just suggesting that it would be beneficial for gamers if HD2 came to xbox. Like sea of thieves did. Don't get in your feels over it.

Magatsuhi4d ago

Its a click bait article. It benefits only xbox to bring a successful game to their failure of a console.

InUrFoxHole4d ago

Lol you big 😠 😡. Just wait till the showcase!

GamerRN4d ago (Edited 4d ago )

Yeah, this site just constantly has so many positive Xbox sm articles, I'm tired of them also... 🙄

z2g4d ago

what a surprise, more basic thinking from basic gamers. the comparison it could be a huge community building game that has a long burn that could also extend to other platforms and or be cross platform. it could be like sea of thieves in that regard etc.... sorry thoughts get more abstract than what your brain can seem to handle

Sonic18814d ago (Edited 4d ago )

Well Helldivers 2 might be releasing on Xbox in the near future

https://n4g.com/news/259589...

+ Show (3) more repliesLast reply 4d ago
Tody_ZA5d ago

I think Helldivers 2 could be PlayStation's Helldivers 2.

Elda5d ago

PS5 gaming console exclusive Helldivers 2 is Helldivers 2 & nothing else.

5d ago
Show all comments (55)
100°

Sea of Thieves on PlayStation 5: the next big Xbox multi-platform game tested

Sea of Thieves stared off life as an Xbox exclusive, growing over time into a genuine hit with a large, committed community. Now, in an effort to increase its audience still futher, it's become a key part of Microsoft's multi-platform push.

Read Full Story >>
eurogamer.net
Einhander19724d ago

So, no one wants to talk about how the PS5 outperforms the xbox version in multiple ways, huh?

purple1014d ago

Draw distance better / shadows better

Also he calls most ps5 “oddity’s” and uses the term “not sure why this is happening” a lot

Ps5 is just more powerful, those 2teraflop difference and Xbox fanatics saying world most powerful console, is worth zip- zero

330°

Sea of Thieves Welcomes 40 Million Players

Joe 'Three Sheets' Neate (Executive Producer): "As I’m sure you can imagine, when it comes to Sea of Thieves my days are full of numbers. Development costs, active servers, days until the next update… Sometimes, though, a truly extraordinary number stands out – a number like 40 million, which I’m incredibly pleased to say is the number of pirates who’ve now set sail in Sea of Thieves!"

Read Full Story >>
seaofthieves.com
darthv728d ago

Garrr... more people to walk the plank and send to Davey Jones locker.

would have been funny to release this on talk like a pirate day.

aaronaton7d ago

I nearly died from cringe reading this...

coolbeans7d ago

Ye wouldn't be any fun on the high seas!

Obscure_Observer8d ago ShowReplies(4)
TrueRican697d ago

I pre-order the premium edition for my PS5 today

Crows907d ago (Edited 7d ago )

40 million have set sail...that's great. How many are sailing now? Monthly active users....when it actually matters. How many people purchased the game is another important number.

Gamingsince19817d ago

You don't get numbers like that from MS mouth pieces, they just like to say stuff like "this game was looked at 129 million time, the biggest amount of people browsing a game of this genre on xbox gamepass ever in the last 3 weeks compared to before gamepass was out (small print only 2 million bothered playing longer than 20 seconds and only 100 people are playing it concurrently)

It's all smoke and mirrors

nibblo7d ago

There are usually around 10,000 concurrent users on Steam not counting Xbox or PS but really it doesn't matter as long as there are enough people on the servers to play which there always were and will be for a long time now with the PS players coming on board. Same goes for how many people bought it and how many are on GP, we aren't the accountants of these console companies so why would we care?

Hofstaderman7d ago

Reporting on MAU stats is very misleading. Other companies publish units sold, MS cannot or will not due to Game Pass. We all know that their prior startegies have not panned out so now they have to actually sell games on other consoles. In any case, SoT is doing impressive preorders on PS5 and will very likely motivate Satya to release more games other than the four indicated games on their competitor's consoles. Take note Phil is radio silent....

Jingsing7d ago (Edited 7d ago )

Yeah Microsoft would tell you the start menu has had 1 billions clicks on Windows 11 to let you know it is beating Windows 10 when the reality is something else. 10,000 concurrent steam users is enough for me to extrapolate there aren't millions playing this on console either. Lets not forget the motivation to bring this to PS5 is already an admission of poor player count. I'd prefer it is Microsoft would just say nothing when it comes to numbers as it makes them look stupid while trying to make everyone else look like an idiot.

+ Show (1) more replyLast reply 7d ago
Abear217d ago

40 Mil across Stream, Windows 10, and Xbox. Healthy numbers for sure, but when PC is the biggest platform, I expected more. It’ll be interesting to see how it does on PlayStation. Very well could be double that player count in 6 months with PS too. It’s crazy for developers to skip the most popular platform, not sure why they’d want to, but they must have had their rea$ons.

Christopher7d ago

PC is the market with the most competition for these type of games as well, so it's actually easier to break in on consoles where these games aren't as prominent.

Show all comments (35)