Top
All Channels
Popular

KingPin

Contributor
CRank: 10Score: 105880

Individual stats in football = nonsense?

say we have two teams (A and B)
with two players, strikers( A1, B1) and midfielders (A2, B2)
now say A1 has a strike rate of 4/5. ie. given 5 chances he will score 4.
and B1 a strike rate of 2/5. ie given 5 chances, he will score 2 for sure.

now say in a 90 minute match against team C
in team A
A2 creates 5 chances, A1 scores 4/5.
therefore A1 = 4 goals. A2 = 4 assists.

in team B
B2 creates 10 chances, B1 scores 4/10
therefore B1 = 4 goals. B2 = 4 assists.

so on paper or statistically speaking
A1 = B1 and A2 = B2. (4 goals and 4 assists)
however for those that actually watched the matches having seen how many chances were created, wasted, scored everyone can agree that A1>B1 and that B2>A2.

thus proving that players stats depends on the team around them not based 100% individually on their own ability.

whats your guys thoughts?

The story is too old to be commented.
jak3y13oy3858d ago

Football has always been a teams game, where do the strikers get the ball from? their midfielders! where did they get the ball from? the defenders/goalkeeper!

Stats are just they're for stats sake, the finisher of the move gets credited (and the assister [is that a word!?]) but that one goal comes from the whole team.. unless the opposition give you the ball.. :L

KingPin3856d ago

that my whole point.
so how can one player take credit for an entire teams work and win an individual award thats based on stats.
what makes goal scorers better players than any midfielder/defender?

so basically you agree that individual stats in football = nonsense.

MajorLazer3851d ago

I agree with you. The team is the one who scored because although 'GK' did not directly score or assist the goal, he was the one who threw the ball far up the field and landed it upon 'ACM's feet who in turn passed to 'x' who in turn scored. If nor for 'GK' and his amazing throw, the goal would not be!

Nes_Daze3840d ago

So you're practically saying there shouldn't be a Balon D Oro right? Because judging based on just team achievements would be even more pointless.

Not trying to counter your arguement btw, at least not yet ;)